Tier 1 approval: options for RedBird
Nov 19, 2026
We recommend Option C, built on B: a bank link or credit check, plus one look by your team before a bidder's first Tier 1 bid. Once approved, later Tier 1 sales open automatically, as agreed on 18 Nov.
The decision
Agreed on 18 Nov: a bidder is approved for Tier 1 once, and later Tier 1 sales open to them automatically. What is open is which step of the profile ladder earns that approval.
A · ID and address (ladder step 2).
B · Bank link or credit check (ladder step 3), as the prototype shows today.
C · A ladder step plus one look by your team before the bidder's first Tier 1 bid.
When an approved bidder is checked again is a separate decision on the board.
What you told us
"We need to know more about the person." (16 Nov, on auctions and high-price items)
"once you get approved to bid on and buy the highest value items ... you're permanently in that category" (18 Nov)
You asked whether there should be "an annual check or confirmation process", then settled on one approval: "the damage they can do is limited" (18 Nov).
Your "option A" on 18 Nov was approving once. It is not Option A on this page, which is about which step earns the approval.
How other houses do it
At every auction house we checked, a person decides who bids on the top lots, and most also ask for financial evidence such as a bank reference, a deposit or a credit check. None opens top lots on ID alone. The one exception we found is the Fanatics Collect marketplace, whose Premier sale approves through a bank-linked application. Pages read 19 Nov 2026 unless marked.
| House | What opens the top lots | How it is decided | Once or per sale |
|---|---|---|---|
| Sotheby's | Premium Lots need a pre-registration application; financial references and a deposit may be required | By Sotheby's, "subject to approval on a lot-by-lot basis" | Per lot |
| Christie's (live, New York) | New bidders, and those with no purchase in 2 years, register "at least 48 hours before an auction begins" with photo ID; a financial reference or deposit may be asked | By Christie's | Carries over; asked again "if you want to spend more than on previous occasions" |
| Phillips (online-only) | Photo ID and proof of address | Registrations "typically reviewed within one (1) business day" | Per sale |
| Propstore | Approval for every auction bidder | "Bidders are approved manually", usually within one business day | Per auction |
| Heritage | Credit from site history, references, bank verification or a credit report; preregister 48 hours ahead | "Credit will be granted at the discretion of Auctioneer." | Carries over as established credit |
| RR Auction | References, bank verification or a credit report; register "at least one full day prior to the actual auction" | By RR, at its discretion | Carries over as established credit |
| Julien's | Government ID for first-time bidders; Julien's may approve or reject | By Julien's | "Each Auction requires a separate registration" |
| Fanatics Collect (Premier, read 16 Nov) | A monthly sale of items at $25,000 and up; a separate application with a linked bank account | Through the bank-linked application | One application |
No house we found says in so many words that approval for top lots carries over to later sales. Christie's comes closest: a returning bidder is asked again only after two years without a purchase, or to spend more than before.
What the rules say
We found no US rule that requires a person to review a bidder; the look in Option C is a business choice. Two points for your legal team:
The credit route needs the bidder's written consent, as on the ladder today.
Tier 1 bidders abroad: Invaluable verifies identity before bids of €7,500 or more in Europe or with European houses, and Propstore runs enhanced checks on UK and EU invoices of €10,000 or more. Your legal team confirms what applies to RedBird's US sales.
Options compared
C protects hero lots best at the cost of one review per bidder, done once; A has no precedent at any house we checked.
| A · ID and address | B · Bank link or credit check | C · B plus one look by your team (recommended) | |
|---|---|---|---|
| For collectors | Fastest: minutes, in the same session | Minutes for a bank link; a credit check can take hours | Up to about one business day, once |
| For consignors and studios | Weakest protection: ID shows who a bidder is, not whether they can pay | Funds checked | Funds checked, plus a person who knows the market |
| Revenue | Most bidders in quickly | Neutral | Neutral when Tier 1 requests open as soon as a sale is public |
| Risk | Highest | A bank balance is a snapshot, so it supports a line but reserves nothing | Lowest |
| Operations | Automatic | Automatic; your team reviews only name mismatches | One review queue, a few minutes per bidder |
| Keeps "approve once" (18 Nov) | Yes | Yes | Yes |
| Who does it | No house we checked | Fanatics Collect Premier | Sotheby's, Christie's, Phillips, Propstore, Heritage, RR Auction |
Our recommendation and why
We recommend Option C, built on B: a bank link or credit check, plus one look by your team before the bidder's first Tier 1 bid. Once approved, later Tier 1 sales open automatically.
It is what collectors meet at the top houses. Sotheby's, Christie's, Phillips and Propstore all put a person's decision in front of top-lot bidding, and Heritage and RR grant credit at their discretion. Tier 1 lots are the pieces worth the most.
ID alone is not a gate anywhere. It tells you who the bidder is, not whether they can pay a hero lot.
A bank link alone matches only one sale we found, Fanatics Collect Premier.
It keeps your 18 Nov agreement. The look happens once per bidder; after that, every later Tier 1 sale opens automatically.
The look is short. Your team sees what the ladder has already collected (card, ID match, bank balance band, lots paid on RedBird, references if given) and chooses approve, approve with a set line, or decline. We suggest a target of one business day, as at Phillips and Propstore. Tier 1 requests open as soon as a sale is public, weeks before its close, so a review never lands at the end of a sale.
The case against, and our answer. A look adds staff time, and if it slips a bidder could miss a sale. It happens once, within a business day, weeks before the close. If your team finds it is only rubber-stamping, it can be switched off in the admin, which turns C into B. Your auction side may instead want approval per sale for hero sales, as at Propstore, Julien's and Phillips. Registering for a sale in one click gives your team the list of who is in each sale without approving anyone twice.
What we take on and what we need from you
Povio builds:
the Tier 1 request, offered from the ladder and from any Tier 1 sale page;
a review queue in the admin showing the bidder's full record, with approve, approve with a set line, or decline, and a logged reason;
a message to the bidder with the decision;
approval carried to every later Tier 1 sale, as agreed on 18 Nov;
a setting to switch the team look off.
We need from you:
Who on your team reviews Tier 1 requests.
The target time; we suggest one business day.
What leads to a decline.
Whether two collecting references can stand in for a bank link (see Bidder checks at each step of the ladder).
How we'll measure it
We report these after every Tier 1 sale; you set the targets.
| Measure | What it tells us |
|---|---|
| Time from Tier 1 request to decision | Whether the look slows bidders down |
| Share of requests decided within one business day | Whether the team keeps to its target |
| Unpaid Tier 1 lots, by value | Whether approval keeps bad bidders out |
| Approved Tier 1 bidders per hero lot | Whether the gate leaves enough competition |
Sources
All read 19 Nov 2026 unless marked. Your words are from our calls on 16 and 18 Nov.
Sotheby's, Guide for Buyers, Premium Lots and financial verification. Read 19 Nov.
Christie's, Conditions of Sale, New York (12 Aug 2024), B1 and B2. Read 19 Nov.
Phillips, Online-only FAQ. Read 19 Nov.
Propstore, General FAQs: auctions. Read 19 Nov.
Heritage Auctions, Terms and Conditions of Auction, clause 6. Read 19 Nov.
RR Auction, Terms and Conditions, sections 2.1 and 11.11. Read 19 Nov.
Julien's Auctions, Terms and Conditions, section 2. Read 19 Nov.
Fanatics Collect, FAQ, Premier. Read 16 Nov.
Invaluable, Bidding FAQ. Read 19 Nov.
Propstore, Terms and Conditions. Read 19 Nov.